| Year | Name | School |
|---|---|---|
| 2026 | Donny Pritzlaff | Columbia |
| 2025 | Doug Schwab | Northern Iowa |
| 2023 | Cael Sanderson | Penn State |
| 2019 | Kevin Dresser | Iowa State |
| 2019 | Scott Goodale | Rutgers |
| 2018 | Cael Sanderson | Penn State |
| 2018 | Pat Santoro | Lehigh |
| 2017 | Brian Smith | Missouri |
| 2016 | Kevin Dresser | Virginia Tech |
| 2015 | Tom Ryan | Ohio State |
| 2014 | Tim Flynn | Edinboro |
| 2013 | Cael Sanderson | Penn State |
| 2012 | J Robinson | Minnesota |
| 2011 | Mark Cody | Oklahoma |
| 2010 | Barry Davis | Wisconsin |
| 2009 | Tom Ryan | Ohio State |
| 2008 | Tom Brands | Iowa |
| 2007 | Cael Sanderson | Iowa State |
| 2006 | Jack Spates | Oklahoma |
| 2005 | Rob Koll | Cornell |
| 2004 | Greg Strobel | Lehigh |
| 2003 | John Smith | Oklahoma State |
| 2002 | Russ Hellickson | Ohio State |
| 2001 | J Robinson | Minnesota |
| 2000 | Bobby Douglas | Iowa State |
| 1999 | Jim Zalesky | Iowa |
| 1998 | Tom Borrelli | Central Michigan |
| 1997 | Dan Gable | Iowa |
| 1996 | T.J. Kerr | Cal State-Bakersfield |
| 1995 | Mark Johnson | Illinois |
| 1994 | John Smith | Oklahoma State |
| 1993 | John Fritz | Penn State |
| 1992 | Rich Lorenzo | Penn State |
| 1991 | Dan Gable | Iowa |
| 1990 | Joe Seay | Oklahoma State |
| 1990 | Tim Neumann | Nebraska |
| 1989 | Marlin Grahn | Portland State |
| 1988 | Bobby Douglas | Arizona State |
| 1987 | Jim Gibbons | Iowa State |
| 1986 | Bob Bubb | Clarion |
| 1985 | Stan Able | Oklahoma |
| 1984 | Tom Chesbro | Oklahoma State |
| 1983 | Dan Gable | Iowa |
| 1982 | Bill Lam | North Carolina |
| 1981 | Rich Lorenzo | Penn State |
| 1980 | Joe Seay | Cal State-Bakersfield |
| 1979 | Thad Turner | Lehigh |
| 1978 | Dan Gable | Iowa |
| 1977 | Duane Kleven | Wisconsin |
| 1976 | Wally Johnson | Minnesota |
| 1975 | Gary Kurdelmeier | Iowa |
| 1974 | Rick Bay | Michigan |
| 1973 | Fred Davis | Brigham Young |
| 1972 | Harold Nichols | Iowa State |
| 1971 | Tom Chesbro | Oklahoma State |
| 1970 | Dale Thomas | Oregon State |
| 1969 | Dave McCuskey | Iowa |
| 1968 | Ed Perry | Navy |
| 1967 | Grady Peninger | Michigan State |
| 1966 | Myron Roderick | Oklahoma State |
| 1965 | Harold Nichols | Iowa State |
| 1964 | Jim Wilkinson | Southern Illinois Edwardsville |
| 1963 | Tom Evans | Oklahoma |
| 1962 | Myron Roderick | Oklahoma State |
| 1961 | Dale Thomas | Oregon State |
| 1960 | Everett Lantz | Wyoming |
| 1959 | Myron Roderick | Oklahoma State |
| 1958 | Harold Nichols | Iowa State |