| Year | Weight | Name | School |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 | 184 | Ty McGeary | West Liberty |
| 2024 | 197 | Derek Blubaugh | Indianapolis |
| 2023 | 149 | Josiah Rider | Adams State |
| 2022 | 285 | Darrell Mason | Minnesota State |
| 2021 | 149 | Lukas Martin | Fairmont St. |
| 2019 | 165 | Shane Ruhnke | Millersville |
| 2018 | 174 | Nick Becker | UW-Parkside |
| 2017 | 157 | DeAndre Johnson | Limestone |
| 2016 | 184 | Joey Davis | Notre Dame |
| 2015 | 165 | Chris Watson | Central Oklahoma |
| 2014 | 133 | Casy Rowell | Central Oklahoma |
| 2013 | 184 | Shamus O'Grady | St. Cloud State |
| 2012 | 197 | Luke McPeek | Adams State |
| 2011 | 197 | Donovan McMahill | Western State |
| 2010 | 133 | Shane Valko | Pitt-Johnstown |
| 2009 | 133 | Joe Kemmerer | Kutztown |
| 2008 | 125 | Cody Garcia | Nebraska-Omaha |
| 2007 | 174 | JD Naig | Nebraska-Omaha |
| 2006 | Hwt | Les Sigman | Nebraska-Omaha |
| 2005 | 184 | Tom Meester | Augustana |
| 2004 | 165 | Waylon Lowe | Findlay |
| 2003 | 133 | Cole Province | Central Oklahoma |
| 2002 | 174 | Todd Fuller | North Dakota State |
| 2001 | 184 | Steve Saxlund | North Dakota State |
| 2000 | 133 | Kris Nelson | North Dakota State |
| 1999 | 125 | Jody Strittmatter | Pitt-Johnstown |
| 1998 | 150 | Travis King | South Dakota State |
| 1997 | 167 | Nate Hendrickson | Moorhead State |
| 1996 | 190 | Chad Lamer | South Dakota State |
| 1995 | 118 | Brian Kapusta | North Dakota State |
| 1994 | 126 | Brian Melchiori | Central Oklahoma |
| 1993 | 134 | Glen Frank | Colorado Mines |
| 1992 | 177 | Mike Leberknight | Northern Colorado |
| 1991 | 167 | Dan Russell | Portland State |
| 1990 | 158 | Dan Russell | Portland State |
| 1989 | 150 | Dan Russell | Portland State |
| 1988 | Hwt | Carlton Haselrig | Pitt-Johnstown |
| 1987 | 184 | Daryl Pope | Cal State Bakersfield |
| 1986 | 190 | Koln Knight | Augustana |
| 1985 | 190 | Koln Knight | Augustana |
| 1984 | 158 | John Davis | Morgan State |
| 1983 | 142 | Jessie Reyes | Cal State Bakersfield |
| 1982 | 142 | Mike Langlais | North Dakota State |
| 1981 | 126 | Dan Cuestas | Cal State Bakersfield |
| 1980 | 177 | Brian Parlet | Augustana |
| 1979 | 118 | Joe Gonzales | Cal State Bakersfield |
| 1978 | 118 | John Azevedo | Cal State Bakersfield |
| 1977 | 134 | Franc Affentranger | Cal State Bakersfield |
| 1976 | 126 | Rick Jensen | South Dakota State |
| 1975 | 118 | Randy Batten | Chattanooga |
| 1974 | 177 | Floyd Hitchcock | Bloomsburg |
| 1973 | 134 | Larry Morgan | Cal Poly |
| 1972 | 150 | Wade Schalles | Clarion |
| 1971 | 150 | Stan Dziedzic | Slippery Rock |
| 1970 | 118 | Terry Hall | Cal Poly |
| 1969 | 152 | Carl Ragland | Old Dominion |
| 1968 | 123 | Rich Sanders | Portland State |
| 1967 | 115 | Rich Sanders | Portland State |
| 1966 | 123 | Warren Crow | SUNY Albany |