| 2026 | Brandon Newill | University of Pittsburgh at Johnstown | wrestler |
| 2026 | Eric Bates | Illinois State University | wrestler |
| 2026 | Florencio Rocha | California State University-Bakersfield | wrestler |
| 2026 | Franz Affentranger | California State University-Bakersfield | wrestler |
| 2026 | Kris Nelson | North Dakota State University | wrestler |
| 2026 | Terry Hall | Cal Poly University | wrestler |
| 2026 | Ziad Haddad | Kutztown University | wrestler |
| 2025 | Dave Klemm | Eastern Illinois University | wrestler |
| 2025 | Geno Savegnago | Eastern Illinois University | wrestler |
| 2025 | Jim Woods | Western Illinois University | wrestler |
| 2025 | John Finch | California Polytechnic State University | wrestler |
| 2025 | Raufeon Stots | University of Nebraska-Kearney | wrestler |
| 2025 | Steve Costanzo | St. Cloud State University | coach |
| 2025 | TJ Hepburn | University of Nebraska-Kearney | wrestler |
| 2025 | Warren Crow | University at Albany | wrestler |
| 2024 | Donovan McMahill | Western Colorado University | wrestler |
| 2024 | John Davis | Morgan State University | wrestler |
| 2024 | Josh Shields | Mercyhurst University | wrestler |
| 2024 | Mario Morgan | University of Nebraska at Omaha | wrestler |
| 2024 | Matt Meuleners | Northern State University | wrestler |
| 2024 | Roger Singleton | Grand Valley State University | wrestler |
| 2024 | William Smith | Morgan State University | wrestler |
| 2023 | Arsenia Barksdale | Adams State University | wrestler |
| 2023 | Jason Bingaman | Lake Superior State University | wrestler |
| 2023 | Joe Kemmerer | Kutztown University | wrestler |
| 2023 | Kirk Myers | University of Northern Iowa | wrestler |
| 2023 | Phil Johns | Southern Illinois University-Edwardsville | wrestler |
| 2023 | Thad Benton | University of Pittsburg-Johnstown | wrestler |
| 2023 | Trevor Franklin | Upper Iowa University | wrestler |
| 2022 | Adam Cuestas | California State University-Bakersfield | wrestler |
| 2022 | Cody Garcia | University of Nebraska-Omaha | wrestler |
| 2022 | Dan Cuestas | California State University-Bakersfield | wrestler |
| 2022 | Joe Gonzales | California State University-Bakersfield | wrestler |
| 2022 | John Azevedo | California State University-Bakersfield | wrestler |
| 2022 | Kamaru Usman | University of Nebraska-Kearney | wrestler |
| 2022 | Lazaro Reinoso | Carson-Newman University | wrestler |
| 2022 | Mike Gallego | Fresno State University | wrestler |
| 2022 | Randy Batten | University of Tennessee-Chattanooga | wrestler |
| 2022 | Todd Meneely | University of Nebraska-Omaha | wrestler |
| 2020 | Brett Hunter | Chadron State College | wrestler |
| 2020 | Brian Kapusta | North Dakota State University | wrestler |
| 2020 | Jack Maughan | University of Northern Colorado | coach |
| 2020 | Jason Reitmeier | Augustana University | coach |
| 2020 | Josh Majerus | Chadron State College | wrestler |
| 2020 | Mike Leberknight | University of Northern Colorado | wrestler |
| 2020 | Paul Carlson | North Dakota State University | wrestler |
| 2019 | Andy Uhl | University of Findlay | wrestler |
| 2019 | Antonio Guerra | University of Findlay | wrestler |
| 2019 | Lee Schickel | University of Pittsburgh at Johnstown | wrestler |
| 2019 | Shad Benton | University of Pittsburgh at Johnstown | wrestler |
| 2019 | Shane Valko | University of Pittsburgh at Johnstown | wrestler |
| 2019 | Shawn Nelson | University of Findlay | coach |
| 2018 | Jason Rhoten | Minnesota State University-Mankato | wrestler |
| 2018 | Kyle Evans | University of Central Oklahoma | wrestler |
| 2018 | Marc Bauer | University of Nebraska-Kearney | coach |
| 2018 | Tervel Dlagnev | University of Nebraska-Kearney | wrestler |
| 2018 | Travis Eggers | Upper Iowa University | wrestler |
| 2017 | Anthony Amado | Portland State University | wrestler |
| 2017 | Broderick Lee | Portland State University | wrestler |
| 2017 | Dan Russell | Portland State University | wrestler |
| 2017 | Hiag Brown | Portland State University | wrestler |
| 2017 | James Sisson | Portland State University | wrestler |
| 2017 | Marlin Grahn | Portland State University | coach |
| 2017 | Tony Champion | Portland State University | wrestler |
| 2017 | Travis West | Portland State University | wrestler |
| 2016 | George Thompson | North Dakota State University | wrestler |
| 2016 | Matt Petsinger | Minnesota State University-Mankato | wrestler |
| 2016 | Nick Severson | North Dakota State University | wrestler |
| 2016 | Pat Dorn | South Dakota State University | wrestler |
| 2016 | Ryan Resel | South Dakota State University | wrestler |
| 2016 | Ryan Wolters | North Dakota State University | wrestler |
| 2016 | Sam Herriman | Augustana University | wrestler |
| 2016 | Steve Saxlund | North Dakota State University | wrestler |
| 2016 | Todd Fuller | North Dakota State University | wrestler |
| 2016 | Tom Meester | Augustana University | wrestler |
| 2015 | Chad Wallace | University of Nebraska at Omaha | wrestler |
| 2015 | Don Stevens | Southern Illinois University-Edwardsville | wrestler |
| 2015 | JD Naig | University of Nebraska at Omaha | wrestler |
| 2015 | Jason Liles | South Dakota State University | coach |
| 2015 | Kip Kristoff | Southern Illinois University-Edwardsville | wrestler |
| 2015 | Les Sigman | University of Nebraska at Omaha | wrestler |
| 2015 | Mack LaRock | University of Nebraska at Omaha | wrestler |
| 2015 | Mark Kristoff | Southern Illinois University-Edwardsville | wrestler |
| 2015 | Merrick Meyer | Truman State University | wrestler |
| 2015 | Paul Konechne | South Dakota State University | wrestler |
| 2014 | Carlton Haselrig | University of Pittsburgh at Johnstown | wrestler |
| 2014 | Corey Kline | Ashland University | wrestler |
| 2014 | Don Henry | Gannon University | coach |
| 2014 | Jody Strittmatter | University of Pittsburgh at Johnstown | wrestler |
| 2014 | John Strittmatter | University of Pittsburgh at Johnstown | wrestler |
| 2014 | Wade Schalles | Clarion University | wrestler |
| 2013 | Cole Province | University of Central Oklahoma | wrestler |
| 2013 | James Makovsky | Minnesota State University - Mankato | coach |
| 2013 | Mark Dodgen | University of Central Oklahoma | wrestler |
| 2013 | Mauricio Wright | San Francisco State University | wrestler |
| 2013 | Morris Johnson | San Francisco State University | wrestler |
| 2013 | Scott Ritzen | Chadron State College | coach |
| 2013 | Shawn Silvis | University of Central Oklahoma | wrestler |
| 2012 | Chris Currier | Colorado State University-Pueblo | wrestler |
| 2012 | Dan Lewis | Colorado School of Mines | coach |
| 2012 | Dax Charles | Colorado State University-Pueblo | wrestler |
| 2012 | Doug Moses | University of Southern Colorado-Pueblo | coach |
| 2012 | Glen Frank | Colorado School of Mines | wrestler |
| 2012 | John Simpson | Colorado School of Mines | wrestler |
| 2012 | Troy Barbush | University of Pittsburgh at Johnstown | wrestler |
| 2011 | Bob Hollingshead | Western State College of Colorado | wrestler |
| 2011 | Frank Kuchera | University of Nebraska at Kearney | wrestler |
| 2011 | Jeff Sylvester | University of Nebraska at Kearney | wrestler |
| 2011 | Shane Carwin | Western State College of Colorado | wrestler |
| 2010 | Braumon Creighton | University of Nebraska at Omaha | wrestler |
| 2010 | Brian Melchiori | University of Central Oklahoma | wrestler |
| 2010 | Chris Blair | University of Nebraska at Omaha | wrestler |
| 2010 | Corry Royal | University of Nebraska at Omaha | wrestler |
| 2010 | Jerry Best | University of Central Oklahoma | wrestler |
| 2010 | Mark Cunningham | University of Central Oklahoma | wrestler |
| 2010 | Nathan Hendrickson | Minnesota State Univ- Moorhead | wrestler |
| 2010 | Robin Ersland | University of Central Missouri | coach |
| 2008 | Gary Bentrim | University of Northern Iowa | wrestler |
| 2008 | Howie Gangestad | Minnesota State University-Mankato | wrestler |
| 2008 | Larry Amundson | Minnesota State University-Mankato | wrestler |
| 2008 | Tony Kenning | Minnesota State University-Mankato | wrestler |
| 2007 | Ali Eliasi | University of Nebraska at Kearney | wrestler |
| 2007 | Bill Dotson | University of Northern Iowa | wrestler |
| 2007 | Mike Keim | University of Central Oklahoma | wrestler |
| 2007 | Todd Drake | University of Central Oklahoma | wrestler |
| 2007 | Wes White | University of Central Oklahoma | wrestler |
| 2006 | Alan Grammar | Southern Illinois University-Edwardsville | wrestler |
| 2006 | Lars Jensen | San Francisco State University | coach |
| 2006 | PJ Smith | University of North Carolina at Pembroke | coach |
| 2006 | Tim Wright | Southern Illinois University-Edwardsville | wrestler |
| 2005 | David James | University of Central Oklahoma | coach |
| 2005 | Greg Wilcox | University of Nebraska at Omaha | wrestler |
| 2005 | Howard Moore | University of Central Oklahoma | wrestler |
| 2005 | Joe Wypiszenski | University of Nebraska at Omaha | wrestler |
| 2005 | Keith Cunningham | University of Central Oklahoma | wrestler |
| 2005 | Randy Zellner | University of Central Oklahoma | wrestler |
| 2005 | Scott Ruff | University of Nebraska at Omaha | wrestler |
| 2004 | Bob Soulek | Minnesota State University-Mankato | wrestler |
| 2004 | Booker Benford | Southern Illinois University-Edwardsville | wrestler |
| 2004 | Chad Lamer | South Dakota State University | wrestler |
| 2004 | Jack Eustice | Minnesota State University-Mankato | wrestler |
| 2004 | Jim Gale | Minnesota State University-Mankato | wrestler |
| 2004 | Lee Petersen | North Dakota State University | wrestler |
| 2004 | Mike Langlais | North Dakota State University | wrestler |
| 2003 | Jeff Esmont | Ashland University | wrestler |
| 2003 | Ken Hackman | California University of Pennsylvania | wrestler |
| 2003 | Pat Pecora | University of Pittsburgh at Johnstown | coach |
| 2003 | Stan Dziedzic | Slippery Rock University | wrestler |
| 2003 | Vince Monseau | West Liberty State College | coach |
| 2002 | Ed Aliverti | Edmonds | meritorious service |
| 2002 | Mark Burrell | Central Missouri State University | wrestler |
| 2002 | Mike Hahesy | Edinboro University of PA | wrestler |
| 2002 | Ted Price | University of Wisconsin-Parkside | wrestler |
| 2001 | Al Rozman | Western State College of Colorado | wrestler |
| 2001 | Dale Stryker | Western State College of Colorado | wrestler |
| 2001 | Glen Younger | Western State College of Colorado | wrestler |
| 2001 | Jim Fallis | University of Northern Colorado | meritorious service |
| 2001 | Mike Pantoya | University of Northern Colorado | wrestler |
| 2000 | Brian Parlet | Augustana College | wrestler |
| 2000 | Don Parker | University of Northern Iowa | wrestler |
| 2000 | Jeff Hohertz | South Dakota State University | wrestler |
| 2000 | Jim Koch | University of Wisconsin-Parkside | coach |
| 2000 | Kent Osboe | University of Northern Iowa | wrestler |
| 2000 | Paul Kendle | Augustana College | coach |
| 2000 | Rick Jensen | South Dakota State University | wrestler |
| 2000 | Tom Kline | Cal Poly University | wrestler |
| 1999 | Jim Miller | University of Northern Iowa | wrestler |
| 1999 | Ken Snyder | University of Northern Iowa | wrestler |
| 1999 | Mark Manning | University of Nebraska at Omaha | wrestler |
| 1999 | Mark Rigatuso | University of Nebraska at Omaha | wrestler |
| 1999 | Mike Denney | University of Nebraska at Omaha | coach |
| 1999 | Mike McCready | University of Northern Iowa | wrestler |
| 1999 | R.J. Nebe | University of Nebraska at Omaha | wrestler |
| 1999 | Rummy Macias | Mankato State University | coach |
| 1998 | Glenn Anderson | Cal Poly University | wrestler |
| 1998 | John Woods | Cal Poly University | wrestler |
| 1998 | Ken Bos | Cal Poly University | wrestler |
| 1998 | Larry Morgan | Cal Poly University | wrestler |
| 1998 | Tom Beeson | Western State of Colorado | wrestler |
| 1998 | Vaughan Hitchcock | Cal Poly University | coach |
| 1997 | "Arthur ""Bucky"" Maugha" | North Dakota State University | coach |
| 1997 | Bill Demeray | North Dakota State University | wrestler |
| 1997 | Brad Rheingans | North Dakota State University | wrestler |
| 1997 | Doug Parker | Springfield College | coach |
| 1997 | Jeff Blatnick | Springfield College | wrestler |
| 1997 | Koln Knight | Augustana College | wrestler |
| 1996 | Chuck Patten | University of Northern Iowa | coach |
| 1996 | Chuck Seal | Portland State University | wrestler |
| 1996 | Jack Hancock | Colorado School of Mines | coach |
| 1996 | Larry Kristoff | Southern Illinois University-Edwardsville | coach and wrestler |
| 1996 | Masaru Yatabe | Portland State University | wrestler |
| 1996 | Rick Sanders | Portland State University | wrestler |
| 1996 | Tracy Borah | Western State of Colorado | coach |
| 1996 | Warren Williamson | South Dakota State University | coach |