| Year | Weight | Name | School |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | 157 | Gabe Johnson | Central Oklahoma |
| 2025 | 184 | Ty McGeary | West Liberty |
| 2024 | 184 | Ty McGeary | West Liberty |
| 2023 | 285 | Shawn Sreck | Central Oklahoma |
| 2022 | 285 | Darell Mason | Minnesota State |
| 2021 | 285 | Kameron Teacher | St. Cloud State |
| 2020 | 184 | Heath Gray | Central Oklahoma |
| 2019 | 125 | Carlos Jacquez | Lindenwood |
| 2018 | 174 | Nick Becker | UW-Parkside |
| 2017 | 174 | Nick Becker | UW-Parkside |
| 2016 | 184 | Joey Davis | Notre Dame |
| 2015 | 165 | Chris Watson | Central Oklahoma |
| 2014 | 285 | Ziad Haddad | Kutztown |
| 2013 | 285 | Tyrell Fortune | Grand Canyon |
| 2012 | 133 | Trevor Franklin | Upper Iowa |
| 2011 | 197 | Donovan McMahill | Western State |
| 2010 | 133 | Shane Valko | Pitt-Johnstown |
| 2009 | 157 | Todd Meneely | Nebraska-Omaha |
| 2008 | 285 | Tervel Dlagnev | Nebraska-Kearney |