| Year | Name | School |
|---|---|---|
| 2026 | Nate Yetzer | Roanoke |
| 2023 | Lonnie Morris | Johnson & Wales |
| 2019 | Jim Moulsoff | Augsburg |
| 2019 | Lonnie Morris | Johnson & Wales |
| 2018 | Marty Nichols | Ithaca |
| 2017 | Lonnie Morris | Johnson & Wales |
| 2016 | Bryan Brunk | Messiah College |
| 2015 | Jim Moulsoff | Augsburg |
| 2014 | Bryan Brunk | Messiah College |
| 2013 | Steve Marinetti | Elmhurst College |
| 2012 | Tim Fader | UW-Whitewater |
| 2011 | Marty Nichols | Ithaca College |
| 2010 | Mark Matzek | Augsburg |
| 2009 | Jim Miller | Wartburg |
| 2008 | John Oostendorp | Coe |
| 2007 | Jeff Swenson | Augsburg |
| 2006 | Tim Kessler | York (PA) |
| 2005 | Steve Marinetti | Elmhurst |
| 2004 | David Mitchell | Luther |
| 2003 | Jim Miller | Wartburg |
| 2002 | Heath Grimm | Upper Iowa |
| 2001 | Tim Fader | Wisconsin-La Crosse |
| 2000 | Jeff Swenson | Augsburg |
| 1999 | Jim Miller | Wartburg |
| 1998 | Jeff Swenson | Augsburg |
| 1997 | Roger Crebs | Lycoming |
| 1996 | Jim Miller | Wartburg |
| 1995 | Jeff Swenson | Augsburg |
| 1994 | John Murray | Ithaca |
| 1993 | Jim Miller | Wartburg |
| 1992 | Don Murray | Brockport State |
| 1991 | Jeff Swenson | Augsburg |
| 1990 | Al Baxter | Buena Vista |
| 1989 | Ed Michael | Buffalo |
| 1988 | John Clark | St. Lawrence |
| 1987 | Dave Icenhower | Trenton State |
| 1986 | Steve Strellner | Montclair State |
| 1985 | Ron Johnson | Central (IA) |
| 1984 | Steve Erber | Binghamton |
| 1983 | Doug Duffy | Minnesota State |
| 1982 | James Howard | Oswego State |
| 1981 | Don Murray | Brockport State |
| 1980 | Don Murray | Brockport State |
| 1979 | David Icenhower | Trenton State |
| 1978 | Jerry Swope | Millersville |
| 1977 | Frank Cheek | Humboldt State |
| 1976 | Chris Ford | Ashland |
| 1975 | Larry Schiacchetano | Montclair State |
| 1974 | Tony Decario | John Carroll |