| 2026 | Alan Boucher | | official |
| 2026 | Clayton Rush | Coe College | wrestler |
| 2026 | John Oostendorp | Coe College | coach |
| 2026 | Mike Howard | Oswego State | coach |
| 2026 | Mike Surak | Millikin University | contributor |
| 2026 | Nick Slack | Augsburg University | wrestler |
| 2025 | Brian Anderson | Wabash College | coach |
| 2025 | Brian Manzi | | official |
| 2025 | Ken Daws | | official |
| 2025 | Minga Batsukh | St. John's University | wrestler |
| 2025 | Riley LeFever | Wabash College | wrestler |
| 2024 | Bryon Tate | Wartburg College | wrestler |
| 2024 | Dave Malecek | University of Wisconsin-La Crosse | coach |
| 2024 | Dave Miller | Wabash College | contributor |
| 2024 | Lucas Malmberg | Messiah University | wrestler |
| 2024 | Nazar Kulchytskyy | University of Wisconsin-Oshkosh | wrestler |
| 2024 | Rick Cole | | official |
| 2024 | Rick Stahl | | official |
| 2023 | Babeto Yewah | University of Wisconsin-La Crosse | wrestler |
| 2023 | Brian Allen | Johnson and Wales University | coach |
| 2023 | John Malvik | Augustana College | contributor |
| 2023 | Mark Matzek | Augsburg University | wrestler/coach |
| 2023 | Michael Blair | Trinity College | wrestler |
| 2023 | Minga Batsukh | Saint John's University | wrestler |
| 2022 | Dwayne Dawson | Western New England University | coach |
| 2022 | Florian Ghinea | Montclair State University | wrestler |
| 2022 | John Barrick | Northeast Region | contributor |
| 2022 | Josh Chell | University of Wisconsin-La Crosse | wrestler |
| 2022 | Marcus Levesseur | Augsburg University | wrestler |
| 2022 | Nik Lewandowski | Augsburg University | wrestler |
| 2020 | Aaron Wernimont | Wartburg College | wrestler |
| 2020 | Daniel Laurent | University of Wisconsin-La Crosse | wrestler |
| 2020 | Perry Miller | University of Wisconsin-Stevens Point | wrestler |
| 2020 | Pete Gonzalez | Montclair State University | wrestler |
| 2020 | Tim Clouse | Rhode Island College | coach |
| 2019 | Donny Wichmann | Augsburg College | coach |
| 2019 | John Gemmel | Ithaca College | wrestler |
| 2019 | Leo Kocher | University of Chicago | coach |
| 2019 | Lonnie Morris | Johnson and Wales University | coach |
| 2019 | Phil Grebinar | Worcester Polytechnic Institute | coach |
| 2019 | Tim Jacoutot | The College of New Jersey | wrestler |
| 2018 | Blake Gillis | Wartburg College | wrestler |
| 2018 | Bruce Haberli | New York University | coach |
| 2018 | Marty Nichols | Ithaca College | coach |
| 2018 | Mike Duroe | Cornell College | coach |
| 2018 | Phil Lanzatella | St. Lawrence University | wrestler |
| 2018 | Stephen Rivera | Trenton State College | wrestler |
| 2017 | Brandon Novak | St. John’s University | wrestler |
| 2017 | Greg Lonning | UW-La Crosse/Central | coach |
| 2017 | Jeff O’Gara | UW-La Crosse | wrestler |
| 2017 | Steff Sair | SUNY-Cortland | wrestler |
| 2017 | Tim Fader | UW-Eau Claire | coach |
| 2016 | Akeem Carter | Wartburg College | wrestler |
| 2016 | Bob Gaudenzi | Hunter College | coach |
| 2016 | Cody Koenig | UW-Stevens Point | wrestler |
| 2016 | Dick Simmons | Cornell College | contributor |
| 2016 | Henry Gerten | Augsburg College | wrestler |
| 2016 | Jimmy Wallace | Wilmington College | wrestler |
| 2016 | Randy Steward | Loras College | coach |
| 2016 | Scott Whirley | Augsburg College | coach |
| 2015 | Jason Bovenzi | St. Lawrence/Ithaca College | wrestler |
| 2015 | Jim Miller | North Central College | coach |
| 2015 | Mike Jacoutot | Buffalo/Trenton State College | wrestler |
| 2014 | Don Parker | UW-Eau Claire | coach |
| 2014 | Dustin Hinschberger | Wartburg College | wrestler |
| 2014 | Jesse Armbruster | Augsburg College | wrestler |
| 2014 | Matt Pyle | Luther College | wrestler |
| 2014 | Scott Stever | Rochester Institute of Technology | coach |
| 2013 | Duane Bastress | York College (Penn.) | wrestler |
| 2013 | Garrett South | Luther College | wrestler |
| 2013 | Gary Franke | Washington and Lee University | coach |
| 2013 | Ryan Allen | UW-La Crosse | wrestler |
| 2013 | Tom Kessler | York College (Penn.) | coach |
| 2012 | Daryl Arroyo | Springfield College | coach |
| 2012 | Joe Hoialmen | Augsburg College | wrestler |
| 2012 | Roger Crebs | Lycoming College | coach |
| 2012 | Tom Hogan | Wartburg College | wrestler |
| 2012 | Yan White | UW-Stevens Point | wrestler |
| 2011 | Dave Kemmy | Roger Williams University | coach |
| 2011 | Gene Nighman | SUNY-Cortland | coach |
| 2011 | Jason Ott | UW-La Crosse | wrestler |
| 2011 | Nick Fornicoia | Augsburg College | wrestler |
| 2011 | Steve Devries | Cornell College | coach |
| 2011 | Terry Shockley | Augustana College | coach |
| 2011 | Zak Kallai | Case Western Reserve University | wrestler |
| 2010 | Dave Mitchell | Luther College | coach |
| 2010 | Don Montgomery | Mount Union College | coach |
| 2010 | LeRoy Gardner | Wartburg College | wrestler |
| 2010 | Steve Gliva | Augsburg College | wrestler |
| 2009 | Dave Novickis | Lawrence University | coach |
| 2009 | Jim Miller | Wartburg College | coach |
| 2009 | Mike Fusilli | Ithaca College | wrestler |
| 2009 | Rick Armstrong | SUNY-Cortland | wrestler |
| 2008 | Garrett Kurth | Luther College | wrestler |
| 2008 | Rich Achtzen | York College (Penn.) | coach |
| 2008 | Ron Beaschler | Ohio Northern University | coach |
| 2008 | Ron Bussey | The College of New Jersey | wrestler |
| 2008 | Zac Weiglein | Wartburg College | wrestler |
| 2007 | Brandon Penzkover | UW-La Crosse | wrestler |
| 2007 | John Beatty | Augsburg College | wrestler |
| 2007 | John Elton | St. Johns University (Minn.) | coach |
| 2007 | Marty Loy | UW-Stevens Point | coach |
| 2007 | Tyrone Fambro | Upper Iowa University | wrestler |
| 2006 | Glen Sandull | The College of New Jersey | wrestler |
| 2006 | Jamal Fox | Wartburg College | wrestler |
| 2006 | Kevin Puebla | Augustana College | coach |
| 2006 | Mike Helm | Messiah College | wrestler |
| 2006 | Russell (Rusty) Carlsten | Rhode Island College | coach |
| 2005 | Gary Kroelss | Augsburg College | wrestler |
| 2005 | Jeff Swenson | Augsburg College | coach |
| 2005 | Mark Ambrose | Delaware Valley University | wrestler |
| 2005 | Mitch Brown | St. Lawrence University | wrestler |
| 2005 | Paul Solberg | Luther College* | coach |
| 2004 | Charles Kunes | Susquehanna University | coach |
| 2004 | Mark Vennis | Thiel College | coach |
| 2004 | Matt Hamill | Rochester Institute of Technology | wrestler |
| 2004 | Mike Connors | St. Lawrence University | wrestler |
| 2004 | Tom Smith | Wartburg College | wrestler |
| 2003 | Bill Racich | Ursinus College | coach |
| 2003 | Dan Lewandowski | Augsburg College | wrestler |
| 2003 | Kerry Volkmann | John Carroll University | coach |
| 2003 | Paul Elsen | Wheaton College | wrestler |
| 2003 | Tom Jarman | Manchester College | coach |
| 2002 | Brandon Totten | Delaware Valley University | wrestler |
| 2002 | John Reese | Wilkes College | coach |
| 2002 | Ned McGinley | King's College | coach |
| 2002 | Neil Turner | Messiah College | coach |
| 2002 | Ron Vosburg | SUNY-Brockport | wrestler |
| 2002 | Shawn Voigt | Cornell College | wrestler |
| 2001 | Al Sosa | SUNY-Oneonta | coach |
| 2001 | Dan Boos | Luther College | wrestler |
| 2001 | Eric Woolsey | Humboldt State University | wrestler |
| 2001 | Peter Wang | University of Chicago | wrestler |
| 2001 | Steve Strellner | Montclair State University | coach |
| 2000 | Al Baxter | Buena Vista University | coach |
| 2000 | Chris Ricklic | Case Western Reserve University | wrestler |
| 2000 | Doug Morse | SUNY-Oswego State | wrestler |
| 2000 | John Leone | SUNY-Brockport | wrestler |
| 2000 | Marty Willigan | Gallaudet University | coach |
| 2000 | Raphael Wilson | Augustana College | wrestler |
| 1999 | Dan Pantaleo | Olivet College | wrestler |
| 1999 | David Icenhower | The College of New Jersey * | coach |
| 1999 | Mark Gamble | SUNY-Binghamton | wrestler |
| 1999 | Nick Milonas | Montclair State University | wrestler |
| 1999 | Ron Zalokar | Carthage College * | coach |
| 1998 | Chris Tironi | University at Albany | wrestler |
| 1998 | John Murray | Ithaca College | coach |
| 1998 | Jon McGovern | Central College | wrestler |
| 1998 | Larry Sciacchetano | Montclair State University | coach |
| 1998 | Mike McCready | Upper Iowa University * | coach |
| 1998 | Travis Young | Simpson College | wrestler |
| 1997 | Bob Skelton | Western New England University | coach |
| 1997 | Jim White | Washington and Jefferson University | coach |
| 1997 | John Monaco | Montclair State University | wrestler |
| 1997 | John Summa | Baldwin-Wallace University * | coach |
| 1997 | Karl Monaco | Montclair State University | wrestler |
| 1997 | Mike McGlinchey | Salisbury University * | coach |
| 1997 | Rob Llorca | UW-Whitewater | wrestler |
| 1996 | Andy Seras | University at Albany | wrestler |
| 1996 | Bob Del Rosa | Case Western Reserve Univ. * | coach |
| 1996 | David Parisi | SUNY-Oswego State | wrestler |
| 1996 | Joe Bertolone | John Carroll University | wrestler |
| 1996 | Joe DeMeo | University at Albany | coach |
| 1996 | Steve Eldridge | U.S. Coast Guard Academy | coach |
| 1995 | Al Hanke | Lake Forest College/Elmhurst College | coach |
| 1995 | Bob Marshall | Delaware Valley University | coach |
| 1995 | Byron James | UW-River Falls * | coach |
| 1995 | Dennis Koslowski | University of Minnesota - Morris | wrestler |
| 1995 | Fran Presley | Millersville University | wrestler |
| 1994 | Bob Glaberman | Trenton State College | wrestler |
| 1994 | John Clark | St. Lawrence University | coach |
| 1994 | Ken Ober | Elizabethtown College * | coach |
| 1994 | Max Servies | Wabash College | coach |
| 1994 | Mike Rossetti | Trenton State College | wrestler |
| 1994 | Nabil Guketlov | Montclair State University | wrestler |
| 1993 | Baron Bremner | Coe College/Cornell College * | coach |
| 1993 | Dick Walker | Wartburg College * | coach |
| 1993 | Gomer Davis | Swarthmore College | coach |
| 1993 | Jeff Bouslog | Luther College | wrestler |
| 1993 | Mark Hawaald | John Carroll University | wrestler |
| 1993 | Ron Winnie | SUNY-Brockport | wrestler |
| 1992 | Don Murray | SUNY-Brockport | coach |
| 1992 | Frank Famiano | SUNY-Brockport | wrestler |
| 1992 | Jare Klein | Olivet College | coach |
| 1992 | Ken Mallory | Montclair State University | wrestler |
| 1992 | Steve Erber | SUNY-Binghamton | coach |
| 1992 | Tom Martucci | Trenton State College | wrestler |
| 1992 | Willie Myers | UW-Whitewater | coach |
| 1991 | Brett Stamm | Wheaton College | wrestler |
| 1991 | Chris Casey | Augustana College | wrestler |
| 1991 | Earl Fuller | Rochester Institute of Technology | coach |
| 1991 | Eric Mast | Elizabethtown College | wrestler |
| 1991 | Jerry Petrofes | Lebanon Valley College | coach |
| 1991 | Jim Howard | SUNY-Oswego State | coach |
| 1991 | Tony DeCarlo | John Carroll University | coach |