| Year | Name | School |
|---|---|---|
| 2019 | Jay Albis | Johnson & Wales |
| 2018 | Lucas Jeske | Ausgburg |
| 2017 | Riley Lefever | Wartburg |
| 2016 | Riley Lefever | Wabash |
| 2015 | Mike Fuenffinger | Augsburg |
| 2014 | Nazar Kulchytskyy | UW-Oshkosh |
| 2013 | Greg Sanders | Concordia University (WI) |
| 2012 | Kodie Silvestri | Wartburg |
| 2011 | Myanganbayar Batsukh | Saint John's (MN) |
| 2010 | Vincent Renau | Merchant Marine |
| 2009 | Michael Wilcox | Delaware Valley |
| 2008 | Josh Chelf | UW - La Crosse |
| 2007 | Matt Pyle | Luther |
| 2006 | Duane Bastress | York (PA) |
| 2005 | Ryan Allen | UW - La Crosse |
| 2004 | Joe Moon | Augsburg |
| 2003 | Remi Ratel | Montclair |
| 2002 | Jimmy Wallace | Wilmington (OH) |
| 2001 | Nick Ackerman | Simpson |
| 2000 | Josh Cagle | Augsburg |
| 1999 | Matt Hamill | Rochester Institute of Technology |
| 1998 | Matt Hamill | Rochester Institute of Technology |
| 1997 | Aaron Fitt | Lycoming |
| 1996 | Ron Vosburg | SUNY Brockport |
| 1995 | Tom Layte | Augsburg |
| 1994 | Raphael Wilson | Augustana (IL) |
| 1993 | Gary Kroells | Augsburg |
| 1992 | Peter Wang | Chicago |
| 1991 | Rob Llorca | UW-Whitewater |
| 1990 | Rob Llorca | UW-Whitewater |
| 1989 | Pete Gonzalez | Montclair |
| 1988 | Tim Jacoutot | The College of New Jersey |
| 1987 | John Monaco | Montclair |
| 1986 | Nick Milonas | Montclair |
| 1985 | Tim Jacoutot | The College of New Jersey |
| 1984 | Bob Glaberman | The College of New Jersey |
| 1983 | Frank Famiano | SUNY Brockport |
| 1982 | Frank Famiano | SUNY Brockport |
| 1981 | Jeff Bouslog | Luther |
| 1980 | Tom Jacoutot | Buffalo |
| 1979 | Jeff Freedman | Ashland |
| 1978 | Ken Mallory | Montclair |
| 1977 | Andy Zook | Millersville |
| 1976 | Vince Tundo | Montclair |
| 1975 | Nabil Guketlov | Montclair |
| 1974 | Jim Fallis | Lake Superior State |