| Year | Name | School |
|---|---|---|
| 2026 | Justin Ensign | Oklahoma City |
| 2023 | Nick Mitchell | Grand View |
| 2019 | Jeff Bedard | Reinhardt |
| 2019 | Nick Mitchell | Grand View |
| 2018 | Joey Martinez | Menlo |
| 2018 | Nick Mitchell | Grand View |
| 2017 | Corey Ruff | Lindsey Wilson |
| 2016 | Nick Mitchell | Grand View |
| 2015 | Nick Mitchell | Grand View |
| 2014 | Nick Mitchell | Grand View |
| 2013 | Nick Mitchell | Grand View |
| 2012 | Nick Mitchell | Grand View |
| 2011 | James Kisgen | McKendree |
| 2010 | Frank Romano | Notre Dame (OH) |
| 2009 | Joe Parisi | Lindenwood |
| 2008 | James Kisgen | McKendree College |
| 2007 | Joe Parisi | Lindenwood University |
| 2006 | Steve Costanzo | Dana College |
| 2005 | Joe Parisi | Lindenwood University |
| 2004 | David Ray | Montana State University-Northern |