| 2019 | Michial Foy | Harper |
| 2018 | Kenny Astle | Western Wyoming |
| 2017 | Preston Lauterbach | Iowa Western |
| 2016 | Jacobe Smith | Northeastern Oklahoma A&M |
| 2015 | Alfredo Rodriguez | Iowa Lakes |
| 2014 | VJ Giulio | North Idaho |
| 2013 | Devin Aguirre | Labette Community College |
| 2012 | John McArdle | Middlesex C.C. |
| 2011 | Jamelle Jones | North Idaho |
| 2010 | Joe Colon | Iowa Central |
| 2009 | Billy Murphy | Iowa Central |
| 2008 | Deron Winn | St. Louis - Meremec |
| 2007 | Tim Elliott | Labette Community College |
| 2006 | Kasey Meiners | Rochester Community College, MN |
| 2005 | Earl Jones | Labette Community College |
| 2004 | Muzaffar Abduraklmanov | Colby |
| 2003 | Chris Nedens | North Idaho |
| 2002 | Willie Parks | Iowa Central |
| 2001 | Nathan Pascoe | North Idaho |
| 2000 | James Huml | Ricks College, ID |
| 1999 | Steve William | Kennedy CC |
| 1998 | Brock Lesnar | Bismarck C.C., ND |
| 1997 | Glenn Garrison | Clackamas |
| 1996 | Marshall Foster | Muskegon |
| 1995 | Gerald Carr | Lassen |
| 1994 | Steve Williams | Iowa Central |
| 1993 | David McCubbins | St. Louis - Meremec |
| 1992 | Alfonso Cruz | Colby |
| 1991 | Joe Wildesin | Garden City |
| 1990 | Steve Carlson | Brainerd |
| 1989 | Jason Roach | Garden City |
| 1988 | Tim McCall | Northeastern Oklahoma A&M |
| 1987 | Pat Whitcomb | North Idaho |
| 1986 | Dan Niebuhr | Madison |
| 1985 | Tom Erickson | Triton College |
| 1984 | Reggie Wilson | Triton College |
| 1983 | Reggie Wilson | Triton College |
| 1982 | Roger Sayles | Mt. Hood |
| 1981 | Karl Lynes | Northeastern Oklahoma A&M |
| 1980 | Jeff Dillman | Joliet JC, IL |
| 1979 | Greg Byrne | Lakeland Community College |
| 1978 | Gregg Moore | Triton College |
| 1977 | Gary Germundson | North Idaho |
| 1976 | Bill Karpowicz | Cuyahoga-West |
| 1975 | Johnnie Jones | Schoolcraft |
| 1974 | Willie Gadson | Nassau CC, NY |
| 1973 | Ron Ray | Wright |
| 1972 | Tim Williams | Clackamas |
| 1971 | Joe Hatchett | North Iowa CC |
| 1970 | John Scanlon | Orange |
| 1969 | Les Armes | Black Hawk |
| 1968 | John Lightner | Garden City |
| 1967 | Darrell Keller | Columbia Basin |
| 1966 | Gary Seymour | SUNY-Morrisville |
| 1965 | Luis Baiz | Phoenix College, AZ |
| 1964 | Darold Henry | Lamar |
| 1963 | Marvin Groves | Phoenix |
| 1962 | Ron Jacobsen | Lamar |
| 1961 | Jerry Hines | Mesa |
| 1960 | Jim Crothers | Alfred |