| 2019 | Austin Devoe | Colorado School of Mines |
| 2018 | Heath Eslinger | Tennessee Chattanooga |
| 2018 | Mike Wehler | Mercyhurst |
| 2013 | Mike Wheeler | Mercyhurst |
| 2012 | Don Garriott | Cerritos College |
| 2012 | Don Henry | Gannon |
| 2012 | Franky James | Campbellsiville |
| 2012 | Mark Manning | Nebraska |
| 2011 | Brendan Buckley | Columbia |
| 2011 | Mike Tellez | Rio Hondo College |
| 2011 | Ron Beaschler | Ohio Northern |
| 2011 | Scott Norton | Highline Community College |
| 2011 | Steve Costanzo | St. Cloud State |
| 2011 | Tim Jager | Morningside College |
| 2010 | Dave Pacheco | Sacramento City College |
| 2010 | Jay Weiss | Harvard |
| 2010 | Joe Renfro | Labette Community College |
| 2010 | Scott Stever | RIT, NY |
| 2010 | Shawn Kelley | Hastings College |
| 2010 | Shawn Nelson | Findlay |
| 2009 | Caleb Schaffer | University of Great Falls |
| 2009 | Dan Dicenzo | Williams College |
| 2009 | David Schutter | Truman State |
| 2009 | Joe Dansby | Cuesta College |
| 2009 | Joe Renfro | Labette Community College |
| 2009 | Mark Cody | American University |
| 2009 | Rafael Vega | Williams College |
| 2008 | Clark Bentley | Muskegon |
| 2008 | David James | Central Oklahoma |
| 2008 | Kerry McCoy | Stanord University |
| 2008 | Richard Fergola | Dana College |
| 2008 | Robert Del Rosa | Case Western Reserve University |
| 2008 | Vince Silva | Santa Ana College |
| 2007 | Clar Anderson | Duke University |
| 2007 | Jeff Swenson | Augsburg |
| 2007 | Larry Watanabe | Mount San Antonio College |
| 2007 | Mike Haluska | Clackamas |
| 2007 | Mike Ritchey | Southern Oregon |
| 2007 | Steve Kimple | Colorado Mines |
| 2006 | Brad Fischer | Wentworth Military Academy |
| 2006 | Dave Amato | Brown University |
| 2006 | Jared Swint | Cumberland (TN) |
| 2006 | John Fitzpatrick | Santa Rosa Junior College |
| 2006 | Jon McGovern | University of Dubuque |
| 2006 | Mike Denny | Nebraska Omaha |