| 2026-28 | Jon Sioredas | Cal Poly |
| 2024-26 | Troy Nickerson | University of Northern Colorado |
| 2022-24 | Tony Ersland | Purdue University |
| 2020-22 | Kevin Ward | Army-West Point |
| 2018-20 | Pat Popolizio | NC State |
| 2016-18 | Tom Ryan | Ohio State |
| 2014-16 | Mark Cody | University of Oklahoma |
| 2012-14 | Rob Koll | Cornell |
| 2010-12 | Brian Smith | University of Missouri |
| 2008-10 | Jim Beichner | University at Buffalo |
| 2006-08 | Ron Mirikitani | St. Louis - Meramec |
| 2004-06 | Ron Beaschler | Ohio Northern University |
| 2002-04 | Jack Maughan | University of Northern Colorado |
| 2000-02 | Roger Reina | University of Pennsylvania |
| 1997-99 | Rande Stottlemyer | University of Pittsburgh |
| 1994-96 | T.J. Kerr | Cal. State Bakersfield |
| 1992-93 | Jack Childs | Drexel University |
| 1990-91 | Roger Sanders | Bloomsburg State College |
| 1988-89 | Don Briggs | University of Northern Iowa |
| 1986-87 | Jim Howard | Oswego State |
| 1984-85 | Bob Carlson | Utah State |
| 1983 | Charles Patton | Northern Iowa |
| 1982 | Bob Ericson | Diablo Valley JC, CA |
| 1981 | Gerald Leeman | Lehigh |
| 1980 | Chris Ford | Ohio State |
| 1979 | Bill Martell | University of California - Berkeley |
| 1978 | Clyde Whitman | East Stroudsburg State |
| 1977 | Romito Macias | Mankato State University |
| 1976 | Bill Nelson | University of Arizona |
| 1975 | John Johnston | Princeton |
| 1974 | Bill Schmitt | Granite City HS, Ill. |
| 1973 | Fred Davis | Brigham Young University |
| 1972 | Ed Peery | U.S. Naval Academy |
| 1971 | Grady Peninger | Michigan State |
| 1970 | Karl Kitt | U.S. Air Force Academy |
| 1969 | LeRoy Alitz | U.S. Military Academy |
| 1968 | Jim Wilkinson | Southern Illinois |
| 1967 | Marv Hess | University of Utah |
| 1966 | Dick Voliv | Rutgers |
| 1965 | Sam Barnes | University of North Carolina |
| 1964 | Fritz Knorr | Kansas State |
| 1963 | Wally Johnson | University of Minnesota |
| 1962 | Robert Pickett | Harvard |
| 1961 | John Hancock | Colorado State |
| 1960 | Harold Nichols | Iowa State |
| 1959 | Frank Finger | University of Virginia |
| 1958 | Ray Jenkins | University of Colorado |
| 1957 | Charles Speidel | Penn State |
| 1956 | Arnold Umbach | Auburn |
| 1955 | Clifford Keen | University of Michigan |
| 1954 | Ray Sparks | Springfield College |
| 1953 | Claude Sharer | Case Technical College |
| 1952 | David C. Bartelma | University of Minnesota |
| 1951 | Dave H. McCuskey | Iowa State Teachers College |
| 1950 | Julius F. Wagner | Colorado A&M |
| 1949 | William Sheridan | Lehigh |
| 1948 | H.E. Kenney | University of Illinois |
| 1947 | Art Griffith | Oklahoma A&M |
| 1943-46 | Fendley Collins | Michigan State |
| 1942 | James Reed | Princeton |
| 1941 | H.E. Kenney | University of Illinois |
| 1940 | C.W. Mayser | Franklin & Marshall |
| 1939 | B.R. Patterson | Kansas State |
| 1938 | Charles Speidel | Penn State |
| 1937 | Paul V. Keen | University of Oklahoma |
| 1934-36 | William Sheridan | Lehigh |
| 1933 | E.C. Gallagher | Oklahoma A&M |