| Name | School | Role |
|---|---|---|
| Duane Bastress | York College (Penn.) | wrestler |
| Garrett South | Luther College | wrestler |
| Gary Franke | Washington and Lee University | coach |
| Ryan Allen | UW-La Crosse | wrestler |
| Tom Kessler | York College (Penn.) | coach |
NCAA Division III Men · Hall of Fame
5 winners
| Name | School | Role |
|---|---|---|
| Duane Bastress | York College (Penn.) | wrestler |
| Garrett South | Luther College | wrestler |
| Gary Franke | Washington and Lee University | coach |
| Ryan Allen | UW-La Crosse | wrestler |
| Tom Kessler | York College (Penn.) | coach |
National Wrestling Coaches Association · nwcaonline.com