| Year | Name | School | State |
|---|---|---|---|
| — | Beauford Haizli | South, Omaha | Nebraska |
| — | Bill Ryder | Grants Pass | Oregon |
| — | Bill Schmitt | Granite City | Illinois |
| — | Bill Wilson | Northern Pontiac | Michigan |
| — | Billy Martin | Granby, Norfolk | Virginia |
| — | Bob Siddens | West Waterloo | Iowa |
| — | Chris Poff | Neshaminy, Langhorne | Pennsylvania |
| — | Darrell Haflein | Golden | Colorado |
| — | Dave Natvig | East, Waterloo | Iowa |
| — | Dave Spencer | McCallie, Chattanooga | Tennessee |
| — | Dennis Powell | Tempe | Arizona |
| — | Dick Black | Owatonna | Minnesota |
| — | Donald Jackson | Smithtown Central, St. James | New York |
| — | Earl Helmbrec | Brandywine, Wilmington | Delaware |
| — | Elias George | Evanston Township | Illinois |
| — | Eugene Gibbons | John Marshall, Cleveland | Ohio |
| — | Frank Bissell | The Hillside School, Pottstown | Pennsylvania |
| — | George Bender | Parkside, Jackson | Michigan |
| — | Harvey Weigle | John Marshall | Oklahoma |
| — | Jack Stanbro | Lindenhurst | New York |
| — | Jim Kinyon | Midwest City | Oklahoma |
| — | Joe Shook | Trinity, Washington | Pennsylvania |
| — | John Dustin | Marshfield, Coos Bay | Oregon |
| — | John J. Goles | Washington | New Jersey |
| — | John P. Farr | Red bank, Chattanooga | Tennessee |
| — | Jug Beck | Sentinel, Missoula | Montana |
| — | Laverne Klar | Mankato | Minnesota |
| — | Leon "Champ" Martin | Algona | Iowa |
| — | Luther Worsham | Baylor, Chattanooga | Tennessee |
| — | Mike Milkovic | Maple Heights | Ohio |
| — | Neal E. Lineman | Reynolds, Greenville | Pennsylvania |
| — | Neil Buckley | Haverford, Haverford | Pennsylvania |
| — | Robert C. Smith | Wray | Colorado |
| — | Ron Park | Clearfield | Pennsylvania |
| — | Thomas E. Robertson | Sidney | New York |
| — | Virgil Milliron | U.S. Grant, Oklahoma City | Oklahoma |