| 2026 | Brock Gutches | Southern Oregon University |
| 2026 | Jimmy May | Baker University |
| 2026 | Mike Ritchey | Southern Oregon University |
| 2026 | Mitchell Lofstedt | Southern Oregon University |
| 2026 | Steve Costanzo | Dana College |
| 2025 | Jameel Bryant | Lindsey Wilson College |
| 2025 | Justin Schlecht | Dickinson State University |
| 2025 | Matt Burns | Grand View University |
| 2024 | Mike Machholz | Missouri Valley |
| 2023 | Bobby Lashley | Missouri Valley |
| 2018 | T.J. Nelson | Western Montana |
| 2017 | David Ray | Montana State University-Northern |
| 2017 | Emmett Willson | Montana State University-Northern |
| 2017 | Turk Lords | Montana State University-Northern |
| 2015 | Nick Cline | Southern Oregon University |
| 2011 | Bubba Taylor | Findlay (Ohio) |
| 2008 | Paul Bartlett | Northwestern College |
| 2007 | Don Payne | Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University |
| 2006 | Chuck Ahsmuhs | Pacific (Ore.) |
| 2006 | Dan Payne | Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University |
| 2006 | Daniel Igali | Simon Fraser University |
| 2004 | Craig Roberts | Simon Fraser University |
| 2004 | John Melling | Simon Fraser University |
| 2001 | Fred Powell | Lock Haven (Pa.) |
| 2000 | Billy Johnson | Fort Hays State (Kan.) |
| 2000 | Chris Wilson | Simon Fraser University |
| 2000 | Don Elia | Carson-Newman (Tenn.) |
| 2000 | Justin Abdou | Simon Fraser University |
| 1999 | Marc Hull | Central State (Okla.) |
| 1999 | Mike Jones | Simon Fraser University |
| 1999 | Vern Tate | Huron (S.D.) |
| 1998 | Spencer Yohe | Hancock (Minn.) |
| 1998 | Steve Tekander | Southern Oregon University |
| 1996 | Bill Hughes | Black Hills State University |
| 1996 | Chris Rinke | Simon Fraser University |
| 1996 | Chuck Pipher | Southern Colorado |
| 1996 | Ed Sernoski | Simon Fraser University |
| 1996 | Johnny Nimmo | Central Oklahoma |
| 1996 | Rodger Jehlicka | Adams State (Colo.) |
| 1996 | Willie Myers | Wisconsin-Whitewater |
| 1995 | Larry McCoy | Indiana (Pa.) |
| 1995 | Mike Rybak | St. Cloud State (Minn.) |
| 1995 | Sam Church | Waynesburg (Pa.) |
| 1993 | Dave McKay | Simon Fraser University |
| 1993 | Jim Koch | Wisconsin-Parkside |
| 1993 | Ken Cox | Lock Haven (Pa.) |
| 1993 | Terry Henry | Central State (Okla.) |
| 1992 | Benny Coleman | Central State (Okla.) |
| 1992 | Charles 'Biff' Walizer | Lock Haven (Pa.) |
| 1991 | Bob Molle | Simon Fraser University |
| 1991 | Brent Lofstedt | Southern Oregon University |
| 1991 | Dave Harvey | Northern State (S.D.) |
| 1991 | Mike Sterner | Southwest State (Minn.) |
| 1991 | Nathan Winner | Southern Oregon University |
| 1991 | Paul Syvrud | University of Jamestown |
| 1991 | Ronnie James | Central State (Okla.) |
| 1990 | Fran McCann | Winona State (Minn.) |
| 1990 | James Tanniehill | Winona State (Minn.) |
| 1990 | William DePaoli | California State (Pa.) |
| 1989 | Bob Whelan | Bemidji State (Minn.) |
| 1989 | Robert Whelan | Bemidji State (Minn.) |
| 1989 | Scott Ritzen | Adams State (Colo.) |
| 1989 | Tony Huck | Valley City State University |
| 1988 | Bob Riehm | Southern Oregon University |
| 1988 | Craig Kelso | Adams State (Colo.) |
| 1988 | David James | Central State (Okla.) |
| 1988 | Ed Aliverti | Edmonds (Wash.) |
| 1988 | Herbert Stanley Jr. | Adams State (Colo.) |
| 1988 | Marc Mongeon | Simon Fraser University |
| 1988 | Mike Clock | Pacific (Ore.) |
| 1987 | Barry Bennett | Concordia-Moorhead (Minn.) |
| 1987 | Jack Ramey | Kearney State (Neb.) |
| 1987 | Jay Roelen | Mission Viejo (Calif.) |
| 1987 | Vince Monseau | West Liberty State (W.Va.) |
| 1986 | Bob Gruner | Wisconsin-Parkside |
| 1986 | Mike Allison | Adams State (Colo.) |
| 1986 | Milton Martin | Westmar (Iowa) |
| 1986 | Rollin Schimmel | Eastern Oregon University |
| 1986 | Willie Meyers | Wisconsin-Whitewater |
| 1985 | Floyd Marshall | Findlay (Ohio) |
| 1985 | Fred Caro | Edinboro State (Pa.) |
| 1985 | Michael Olson | Pembroke State (N.C.)/Jamestown (N.D.) |
| 1985 | Neil 'Doc' Ersland | Westmar (Iowa) |
| 1985 | Robert 'Bobby' Douglas | West Liberty State (W.Va.) |
| 1985 | Robert (Bob) Dettmer | Bemidji State (Minn.) |
| 1984 | Bill Garland | Moorhead State (Minn.) |
| 1984 | Bob Billberg | Moorhead State (Minn.) |
| 1984 | Glenn Guerin | Taylor University |
| 1983 | Clayton Ketterling | University of Jamestown |
| 1983 | Rick Stuyvesant | Moorhead State (Minn.) |
| 1983 | Wade Winters | Westmar (Iowa) |
| 1982 | Lanny Davidson | Eastern Washington |
| 1981 | Bill Mitchell | Central State (Okla.) |
| 1981 | Dennis Warren | Central Washington |
| 1981 | Eric Beardsley | Central Washington |
| 1981 | Gary Smith | St. Cloud State (Minn.) |
| 1981 | Ken Martin | Wisconsin-Parkside |
| 1980 | Jim Fallis | Lake Superior (Mich.) |
| 1980 | Kenneth Melchoir | Lock Haven (Pa.) |
| 1980 | Mel Washington | Nebraska-Omaha |
| 1980 | Rometo Macias | Mankato State (Minn.) |
| 1980 | Roy Washington | Nebraska-Omaha |
| 1980 | William Garson | Bloomsburg State (Pa.) |
| 1980 | William West | Wisconsin-Parkside |
| 1979 | Byron James | Wisconsin-River Falls |
| 1979 | Steve Exline | Upper Iowa |
| 1978 | Dave Hazewinkel | St. Cloud State (Minn.) |
| 1978 | Frank Mosier | Moorhead State (Minn.) |
| 1978 | John Peterson | Wisconsin-Stout |
| 1977 | Bill Blacksmith | Lock Haven (Pa.) |
| 1977 | Bob Jones | Winona State (Minn.) |
| 1977 | Manuel Gorriarian | Hook-Fast Specialties |
| 1977 | Mike Stanley | Adams State (Colo.) |
| 1977 | Russ Houk | Bloomsburg State (Pa.) |
| 1977 | Tony Schavone | Black Hills State University |
| 1976 | Arthur Maughan | Moorhead State (Minn.) |
| 1976 | Dominic Carolla | Adams State (Colo.) |
| 1976 | Lamoin Merkley | Central Washington |
| 1975 | Chester A. Anderson | Bemidji State (Minn.) |
| 1975 | Erling Odegaard | Eastern Oregon University |
| 1975 | Gray Simons | Lock Haven (Pa.) |
| 1975 | James Hazewinkel | St. Cloud State (Minn.) |
| 1975 | Jerry Swope | Lock Haven (Pa.) |
| 1972 | Jerry Wedemeier | Winona State (Minn.) |
| 1970 | Raymond 'Bucky' Murdock | Waynesburg (Pa.) |
| 1963 | Hubert Jack | Lock Haven (Pa.) |