| Name | School |
|---|---|
| Jameel Bryant | Lindsey Wilson College |
| Justin Schlecht | Dickinson State University |
| Matt Burns | Grand View University |
NAIA Men · Hall of Fame
3 winners
| Name | School |
|---|---|
| Jameel Bryant | Lindsey Wilson College |
| Justin Schlecht | Dickinson State University |
| Matt Burns | Grand View University |
National Wrestling Coaches Association · nwcaonline.com